Lula has spoken, and has said little.
In his national address last night -- his first public appearance since the crash days ago - he addressed his "amigos e amigas", leaving many of us wondering if we were included or not. Lula spoke emotively, and I'm sure sincerely, about his sadness for the families and said that Brazil "cannot accept this tragedy." He literally said he had a "bleeding heart."
He did make the anticipated announcements about the downgrading of Congonhas Airport, and putting a 60 day deadline on announcing the location of a new airport serving São Paulo. The one line in which Lula communicated (finally) a semblence of understanding for the challenge was this:
Although Congonhas conforms to all international norms of safety, this isn't enough. With the airport surrounded on all sides by the city of São Paulo, it must follow even more severe safety measures.
Instead of defensively claiming to follow the rules (like the runway being exactly regulation, with no room for error by pilots), he begrudgingly admitted more must be done. But alas, nowhere in Lula's speech was there any sense of responsibility -- personal or political -- for the shameful collapse of the aviation system. No apology, no buck stopping anywhere near him. Nothing to reassure the nation about travel, about the future or about his governance.
And then the
mind-boggling new examples of utter collapse continued to cascade into view.
First,
I watched yesterday on CNN en Español as the leaders of the civil aviation authority of Brazil (ANAC) -- the idiots-in-chief who have cravenly failed at their jobs across the boards -- getting decorated with medals of honor. Actual decorations of valor. See the picture at the left? This is not a joke.
Then, O Globo reported that the Brazilian government did not, as it turns out, ship the cockpit voice recorder to the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board for analysis as had been reported. They erroneously shipped a piece of the plane they thought was the CVR. It was not, as the investigators found out when it was opened. Just a charred piece of the plane. The actual CVR was in a warehouse along with the other recovered pieces of the plane, and was discovered there this morning.
And part three of the shameful hat-trick of idiocy to report today: a short circuit in the Brazilian air traffic radar system near Manaus in the Amazon region yesterday led to the cancellation of nearly half of all today's flights across the country beginning last night at midnight. At least eight international flights turned back in the wee hours before reaching the northern edge of the country's airspace, four alone from American Airlines.
The anger is only boiling up further in Brazil. The families are beginning to shake the trauma of the crash and are beginning to express themselves more directly to the government, and to Lula personally. The widow of Andrei Melo François Mello, a 42-year old consultant from São Paulo who was killed on the flight, has put up two enormous signs in public view, each with the same message to President Lula. The one at Avenida Paulista and Rua Peixoto Gomide is close to my home, while the other is at a busy intersection of Avenida Faria Lima:
PRESIDENT LULA: The day and the hour have arrived. Lay your presidential sash over the tomb of my husband, ANDREI.
My love, my family, my foundation, my life. I'm waiting for you at home. Your Joan of Arc, LILI.
Protests of varying kinds, such as spray-painted messages that say "LUTO" -- or 'in mourning' -- are springing up around São Paulo. A banner stretched across an area near the crash site during a small protest there, playing upon Marta Suplicy's
unfortunately flip attitude in June about the crisis, said: "
MARTA! We won't "relaxa e goza." We are crying and praying."Nobody -- and I mean nobody -- seems to be assuaged or moved or otherwise convinced by Lula's television address last night. The government doesn't seem to realize it. It's deja vu for this American.
Like many, many Americans, the bottom fell out for me over President George W. Bush when I watched the U.S. federal emergency response capability collapse on live television after Hurricane Katrina in September 2005. Memories of 9/11 mixed with the horrific disaster unfolding in Iraq, and I saw an American city being destroyed on TV while my president handed out accolades to the bumbling idiots who were failing to save it. That's when the American nation turned on its president and he never recovered their trust. To this day, Bush still doesn't seem to grasp how badly his government bungled the hurricane response. They still can't accept that they have bungled the Iraq War. Thousands of Americans have died in both. Hence, his party was thrown out in the 2006 elections, and the GOP seems more politically doomed in 2008 than at any time since Watergate.
I think that the crash of TAM 3054 may well be Lula's Katrina. And it could be a turning point for Brazilian democracy. This could be the moment where a battered nation's core, finally fed up, says no more to this miserable Third World existence being served up by an incompetent government when all the resources, all the know-how and all the public will is
there to begin to really change things.
But to be honest, I'm not sure. I can't say my finger is really on the pulse of the Brazilian public so well as to predict it. History has shown Latin American societies put up with far worse, in some cases from overtly brutal regimes. Only in this case, the people of Brazil have been sold a bill of goods on democracy and economic improvement and they've bought it completely. Now they are demanding the goods, and they're not going to take any more crap or lies from some idiot in customer service. With 200 dead bodies involved, and continuing disaster in the system, I don't know a single Brazilian at this stage who wouldn't slam the phone down and say
chega!